Money: Debt And Value Of Labor.

When I start thinking about money, I first think of what exactly? Over the years of thinking about it, mostly from a non-greedy perspective, if that’s possible I go back typically to cavemen. I promised to write this for the working-class average Dave out there. Average Joe is on vacation. Average Jim is in the office. Average Averell is getting old. Average Johannes is in South Africa. Average Edmund is buying cars.

Anyway, there were cavemen and presumably women and they somehow managed without nail cutters and makeup. You call them nail clippers I grew up calling them cutters. Same difference. Six of one; half dozen of another. Anyway, these cavemen and women didn’t have money. I doubt they traded. I think they were pretty much in a cave club or sorts where each person’s life depended on the other. The inhabitants of the cave survived when everyone survived. The cave dwellers thrived when everyone thrived. They probably had arguments over the best chunks of meat. However, they didn’t argue for too long because the next meal or predator was around the corner. I like to think fruit was plentiful, water was scarce, but they had the stomachs for it. Together some of the cave dwellers went after mammoths like Palantir groupies going after the US Military. Other cave dwellers were content with fishing with a spear. Eventually someone figured out that the skin of the tiger could make for a nice sort of present for the cave wifey. She accepted it gladly at first but then got upset when it started to rot. Eventually someone figured out how to make animal skin clothes. And that’s how civilization began.

Now notice that living until then didn’t require any sort of money whatsoever. It was simply the tribe (it had become a tribe by then, getting an upgrade from cave dweller) looked out for the best interests of everyone within it. The tribe had sturdy constitutions especially since no one wore shoes. There is something about calluses on the feet caused by regular walking and running over rough terrain that triggers nerve signals that end up making a person very hale and hearty. The tribe developed fire simply by observing a lighting strike one day and trying to imitate it. That took a few centuries to master. Eventually they got around to a wheel when they found an exceptionally smooth and rounded rock. Making use of the wheel took a few more centuries. And this continued for a long time. Thousands of years went by and agriculture had still not been invented. The myth is that people live short, brutish and banal lives. Especially the neanderthals. I am not so sure about that. Still they must have been born, lived and then died. The quality of those lives is lost to antiquity. The fact that we all exist and are reading this in 27 countries implies that our ancestors didn’t just hit each other on the heads all the time, there must have been moments of love, tenderness and the sheer thrill of living in a primal environment and succeeding.

Somewhere along the way, they discovered agriculture. That led in short order to granaries to store the seed in the winter. And granaries needed guards. And the guards needed a chief. And the chief become important, more important than anyone else. And so greed appeared and what was a cooperative tribe started to fight over grain. Then someone discovered that grain could be made into mead. And ale. And that caused even more ruckus. The people started to petition the chief for access to grain. They gave the chief presents of shiny objects and their daughters. In some tribes the chief called the elders of the tribe into his dwelling to ask for advice. In other tribes, the chief called his guards to raid other tribes and capture their grain and their beautiful women. In some tribes, after the chief died the elders ruled by vote. There are different iterations of all this but you’ll notice that even now there is no discussion of money, there isn’t even an idea of money. The tribe created and provided everything that was required by the tribe - from the youngest to the eldest member.

Then barter must have arrived as a way to form relations between tribes that weren’t at war. The tribes would visit each other and it was always considered to be polite to take something of value when you visited. A haunch of meat, a container of honey, some animal skin clothes or perhaps basic implements made of bronze. The Bronze Age had arrived by then. Those visits were always lovely. Barter was perfectly acceptable form of a relationship one would guess during those times. Money had still not arrived on the scene. Eventually and it’s not known exactly when or where but someone must have thought of a better form of barter perhaps as a way to please the Elders who like shiny objects. That’s how money must have been created through a liking for shiny things like gold, that until then had no value at all. Value was in the mind of the beholder.

The real problem with money began when guards were put in charge of guarding it. The guards would simply issue written notes signed in a mysterious way that only the receiver would understand and would reciprocate. The entire system of money hinges on this reciprocation. If the other person on the receiving end doesn’t reciprocate and acknowledge the value of the note, the system of money breaks down. The guards realized they had a problem. All the guards in all the tribes must be on their side. So they developed a System of ensuring that happened. That no guard anywhere would refuse to acknowledge the notes. The System involved torture, breaking down the other guards under extreme duress, doing unspeakable things to their children and other loved ones and so on until all the guards agreed to accept the notes. The notes mean that money doesn’t have to exist, shiny objects don't have to exist, the only thing that is required is that the notes be accepted everywhere. And the production of these notes is controlled by the guards. The guards became so strong, that even the King had to pay interest on the notes. During wars, the guards would offer notes to both sides to keep fighting. The guards did that because they had realized something important. War was the best reason for requiring notes. Otherwise some people would simply bow out of the System and go back to barter. There always had to be a reason for people wanting the notes. People had to be desirous of those notes. They truly had to want it. They had to become greedy.

And so the guards created taxation. One of guards had that idea. We will force the people to pay us their farm’s output. Or we will accept notes. Whatever they want to give. In other words, the farm’s produce, the people’s food, was the same as notes. And once the people accepted and understood that (they had no choice) the notes became desired. Everybody wanted the notes. Women sold their bodies to get those notes. And if notes were the same as produce, the notes were also the same as labor. And the guards controlled the production of the notes worldwide.

Everything else that they’ve built since then: the fractional reserve banking, the use of money as debt etc… All of that is simply building on this basic foundation of food and labor. That’s how I think, in a very simple model, how money arrived into a moneyless world. The guards became bankers. Bankers become private equity founders. And so on and so forth.

This essay was originally meant to be a reflection on the difference between money as debt and money as a value for labor. When money is created as debt and debt only, then it is always in short supply. Because they’re not creating enough money for the interest. So there is always a scarcity of money even though the total supply of money keeps increasing. The common people are always fighting for crumbs while the rich are always eating cake.

I think it’s pretty clear what I have written. It’s not so complicated as people make it sound if you start from the cave and cavemen.

Previous
Previous

A 10-yr subscription to the F-35.

Next
Next

When Dystopia Is The End Goal.