The Third Leak Of Chips To China: Where The Buck Stops.

Publishers Note:

It was interesting to work on developing this essay. It began as a satire about two tiny bureaucracies that most Americans have never heard of: DDIG (Defense Department’s Inspector General who doesn’t seem to have gotten the memo that the department is now Department of War not Defense) and BIS (Bureau of Industry and Security: a small Bureau at the Department of Commerce). What is the BIS? That was it’s own sort of essay: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1KD3VPDC-14h3Jssy8AuLENxFlZlSO6Vwflp4lDhuLi4/edit?usp=sharing

Ultimately after discarding the satire idea, we developed this essay with multiple AIs. I have extensive research stored on Google Docs to backup everything that is mentioned below. We are now being read in 34 countries including Ukraine. The total number of our readers is still showing as around 200+.

AIs that worked on this include: Gemini Neon on the usual platform, Gemini Neon on Antigravity with 5 different agents, Claude for initial research and subsequent guardrails that were eventually discarded. The diagrams are Claude’s and they’re easy for the average person to understand when dealing with something this complex. The cha cha teng Cantonese satire at the bottom of the essay is also Claude.

https://www.thestar.com.my/aseanplus/aseanplus-news/2026/07/18/us-says-nvidias-h200-exports-to-china-remain-trivial-despite-approvals

Who Holds the Pen? How 879,868 AI Chips Were Approved for China—and the Usual Suspects Who Signed Off

A Sentient Musings Briefing naming the actual executives, Cabinet secretaries, and hidden bureau chiefs behind America's export-control machinery—and why the biggest scandal in Washington is what the law lets them do in plain sight. Current as of November 20, 2026.

The Short Version

On November 19, 2026, the House Foreign Affairs Committee voted unanimously to break statutory secrecy and publish confidential Commerce Department records. As Al Jazeera reported, those files revealed that in just six months—between December 2025 and May 11, 2026—American chipmakers asked to export 3,444,160 advanced AI processors to China, and the Commerce Department's Bureau of Industry and Security (BIS) signed off on 21 licenses covering 879,868 chips: 579,868 Nvidia H200s and 300,000 AMD MI325Xs.

The policy came straight from the top: President Donald Trump reopened China sales for this tier of AI silicon on December 8, 2025, backed by White House AI Czar David Sacks. What detonated the story inside Washington was a November 18 scoop by The Information (summarized by The Next Web), citing three anonymous sources—two on the override point—who said BIS Under Secretary Jeffrey Kessler pressured staff to fast-track Nvidia H200 approvals and, in some cases, instructed them to approve licenses over objections from other U.S. departments.

Strip away the sanitized DC press releases, and something far worse than a rogue bureaucrat comes into focus. This system didn't have to break to clear nearly a million frontier-adjacent AI chips for Beijing. The Pentagon, State, and Energy have no upfront veto. Commerce chairs the first three rungs of the review ladder, the 1995 executive order governing interagency review explicitly forbids anyone from enforcing it in court, and Congress exempted export licensing from ordinary judicial review. Washington's bureaucracy is designed so that nobody has to commit a crime to hand a strategic rival the hardware powering modern warfare and intelligence.

The Usual Suspects: Who Actually Sits in the Chairs

Washington scandals stay sterile when journalists refer to "Commerce," "the Pentagon," and "the interagency" as if buildings sign export licenses. Real people hold these pens—and real people sat in the reviewing chairs while 879,868 chips cleared the desk:

Person & Title Department / Company Role in the 879,868-Chip Approvals
Policy & Final Word
Donald Trump
President of the United States
The White House Announced the Dec. 8, 2025 pivot reopening H200/MI325X sales to China; signed Proclamation 11002 (25% tariff); sits at the top of the 4-rung appeal ladder.
Policy Enforcer
David Sacks
White House AI & Crypto Czar
The White House Publicly fought HFAC Chair Brian Mast's AI OVERWATCH Act in Jan. 2026 to block Congress from gaining veto power over China AI-chip exports.
Holds the Pen
Howard Lutnick
Secretary of Commerce
Department of Commerce Chairs the Cabinet-level Export Administration Review Board (EARB); publicly faulted by Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent over Megaspeed Entity-List delays.
Runs BIS
Jeffrey Kessler
Under Secretary for Industry & Security
Commerce / BIS Runs BIS day-to-day; testified July 14 that H200 shipments had begun; named in The Information's Nov. 18 report as pressing staff to fast-track approvals.
Chairs ACEP
Steven Haines → Noah Jaffe
(Nominee: Abby Warren)
Commerce / BIS
Asst. Sec., Export Admin.
Haines held the ACEP chair during the Dec. 2025–May 2026 approval window before moving to ITA; Jaffe took over as acting head in late May; Warren awaits confirmation.
Defense Review
Pete Hegseth (Sec. of War)
Michael Laychak → Matthew Redding
Dept. of Defense (War) & DTSA Hegseth sits on EARB. Longtime DTSA Director Laychak ran Pentagon dual-use chip reviews during the entire Dec.–May approval window before retiring Sept. 2026 (Redding now acting).
State Review
Marco Rubio (Sec. of State)
Dr. Christopher Yeaw (Asst. Sec.)
Dept. of State & ISN / ACN Rubio sits on EARB and merged State's nonproliferation bureaus; Dr. Yeaw took over as Assistant Secretary in late Dec. 2025, overseeing State's dual-use chip desk.
Energy Review
Chris Wright (Sec. of Energy)
Brandon Williams (NNSA Admin.)
Dept. of Energy & NNSA / NPAC Wright sits on EARB; NNSA Administrator Williams oversees the Office of Nonproliferation and Arms Control, which reviews dual-use chips for nuclear/WMD risk.
Cabinet Critic
Scott Bessent
Secretary of the Treasury
Dept. of the Treasury Non-voting on BIS licenses, but blew open the cabinet feud on CNBC Nov. 13 over Megaspeed delays: "Commerce has the pen."
Exporter #1
Jensen Huang (resigned Nov. 12)
Colette Kress (Interim CEO)
Nvidia Won 17 licenses for 579,868 H200s; Kress disclosed $2.4B in Q3 Hopper China sales and halted licensed Hopper shipments to China on Nov. 17.
Exporter #2
Dr. Lisa Su
Chair & CEO (Huang's cousin)
AMD Won 4 licenses for 300,000 MI325Xs (Tencent, ByteDance, DiDi, Kuaishou); has not disclosed whether any approved MI325X units physically shipped.
Oversight
Brian Mast (R-FL), Gregory Meeks (D-NY), John Moolenaar (R-MI), Tim Scott (R-SC)
U.S. Congress Unanimously forced the Nov. 19 ECRA disclosure; demanding Dec. 1–10 testimony from Huang, Nvidia GC Tim Teter, Kessler, and Lutnick.

Approvals vs. Shipments: What Actually Moved

The four-page BIS table released by Mast's committee covers 54 applications filed between December 2025 and April 2026, frozen as of May 11, 2026. Alongside the 21 approvals (879,868 chips), BIS returned nine applications without action (1,888,950 chips, mostly Chinese-owned data centers in Malaysia, Indonesia, and Thailand), rejected one (75,000 AMD chips for UCloud), and left 23 pending (600,342 chips).

On May 11, every approved license sat at "Approved, not shipped." Two months later, on July 14, Kessler told the House Foreign Affairs Committee—as Reuters reported—that H200 shipments to China had begun, though "very few" had physically crossed. Then came the November collapse. On November 12, Nvidia founder Jensen Huang resigned abruptly amid widely reported scrutiny over an extramarital relationship with former Megaspeed executive Alice Huang (no relation). Five days later, on November 17, interim CEO Colette Kress disclosed $2.4 billion in Q3 sales of licensed Hopper-series data center chips to China—and announced, as Bloomberg Government reported, that Nvidia is no longer shipping licensed Hopper products to China. Neither Nvidia nor AMD has disclosed exact unit counts delivered after May 11.

Official Hearing Footage: FY27 BIS Budget — The AI Arms Race & the ICTS Office (July 14, 2026)

Under Secretary Jeffrey Kessler testifying before the House Foreign Affairs Committee: "For the American people, the bottom line is very few shipments against licenses for H200s and equivalents have taken place." Official House Foreign Affairs Committee recording (watch on YouTube | written statement PDF).

The Other Half of the Family Business: AMD's Quiet 300,000-Chip Pipeline

Nvidia has absorbed almost all the congressional heat—and lost its CEO—while the other half of the American AI-chip duopoly walked away with more than a third of the entire approval pool. AMD, led by Chair and CEO Dr. Lisa Su—who is Jensen Huang's first cousin once removed—secured four identical 75,000-chip approvals totaling 300,000 Instinct MI325X accelerators. The approved buyers were not obscure startups: they were Tencent (via wholly owned subsidiary Oriental Power Holdings), ByteDance (via Beijing Zitiao Network Technology), Beijing DiDi, and Kuaishou, with another 75,000-chip application for Kingsoft still pending as of May 11.

That China exposure is now drawing its own fire. On November 20, investigative outlet Hunterbrook Media (which disclosed a short position in AMD) reported that installers named across the HFAC license files—including Maginfra and Aivres Systems—offered AMD firmware nearly identical to blacklisted Chinese server maker IEIT Systems, and noted that every AMD application nonetheless certified the diversion risk as "low." AMD fired back that the report "misrepresents AMD's business practices and relationships" and reaffirmed that it complies rigorously with U.S. export laws. Yet while Nvidia has publicly shut off licensed Hopper shipments to China, Dr. Su's company has not disclosed whether a single one of its 300,000 approved MI325X chips has crossed the Pacific.

The January Rule, the 25% Toll, and Who Actually Holds the Pen

For years, exporting chips of this power to China faced a presumption of denial. On January 15, 2026, BIS published a final rule in the Federal Register shifting direct U.S. exports of H200 and MI325X chips to case-by-case review under nine conditions—capping China shipments at 50% of U.S. compute sales, barring military end-users and blacklisted cloud access, and forcing every shipment through an independent U.S. lab inside U.S. customs territory. That U.S.-transit requirement interlocked with President Trump's January 14 Proclamation 11002, slapping a 25% Section 232 import tariff on covered chips while exempting U.S. domestic uses—a workaround after an August 2025 deal in which Nvidia and AMD reportedly agreed to pay Washington 15% of China sales on older chips, despite the Export Control Reform Act's explicit ban on charging license fees (50 U.S.C. § 4815(c)) and the Constitution's Export Clause.

When applications arrive at BIS, Executive Order 12981 (1995) gives Defense (DTSA), State (ISN/ACN), and Energy (NNSA/NPAC) 30 days to advise. Silence counts as yes. If an agency objects, the dispute climbs a four-rung ladder—and Lutnick's department chairs the first three:

  1. Operating Committee (OC): Chaired by a Commerce appointee, who decides alone. No vote is taken.
  2. Advisory Committee on Export Policy (ACEP): Chaired by Commerce's Assistant Secretary for Export Administration (Haines, now Jaffe); decides by 3-of-4 majority vote.
  3. Export Administration Review Board (EARB): Chaired by Secretary Howard Lutnick; decides by 3-of-4 majority vote.
  4. The President: Final word, if Hegseth, Rubio, or Wright appeals in writing.

How a chip export license is decided, and who chairs each step

Every coral box is chaired by Commerce. The Pentagon, State and Energy advise for thirty days and may appeal in writing within five days of the chair's decision. If nobody appeals, the chair's decision stands.

How a chip export license is decided An exporter applies to BIS, Defense, State and Energy advise for 30 days, a Commerce chair decides, and any appeal goes through two Commerce-chaired boards before the President. ExporterNvidia or AMD BIS intakeCommerce Chair decidesNo vote taken LicenseGranted Defense, State, Energy30 days to advise; silence = yes if an agency objects AppealWithin 5 days Appeal boardCommerce chairs Cabinet boardCommerce chairs PresidentFinal word Commerce chairs this step Other agencies advise or appeal

The entire burden of escalating falls on the objector: a Senate-confirmed official must appeal in writing within five days, or Commerce's approval stands. That is why Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent's November 13 CNBC explosion—reported by BusinessDay and The Washington Post—struck such a nerve. Faulting Lutnick's Commerce Department for months of inaction on blacklisting Singapore-based Megaspeed despite backing from Treasury, State, War, and USTR, Bessent put the whole architecture in four words: "Commerce has the pen."

Four Military-Listed Giants—and a Calendar Excuse

Nearly a third of the approved chips—272,000—went to four Chinese conglomerates on the Pentagon's Section 1260H list of Chinese Military Companies: Tencent (150,000), Alibaba (75,000), Baidu (43,000), and BYD (4,000). Formally, only Tencent was on the list (added January 2025) when BIS issued the licenses; as Holland & Knight documented, Alibaba, Baidu, and BYD were formally added on June 8, 2026—four weeks after the May 11 cutoff, following a withdrawn February draft. Nobody in Washington is naive about China's military-civil fusion ecosystem, yet a four-week calendar gap handed regulators a convenient shield.

Who Broke the Law? Four Scenarios

When nearly a million high-end AI chips are cleared for Beijing, ordinary citizens instinctively assume a crime was committed. In Washington, grave national security harm and criminal liability are completely separate tracks:

  • Scenario 1 — Valid licenses, compliant shipments: Under the Export Control Reform Act (50 U.S.C. §§ 4811–4813), President Trump and Secretary Lutnick hold sweeping discretionary power. If the licenses were valid and Nvidia and AMD obeyed every rider, no federal crime occurred—however reckless critics judge the policy.
  • Scenario 2 — Kessler or BIS skipped interagency review: Even if BIS violated EO 12981 or its own Part 750 rules, no court can intervene. Section 7 of EO 12981 bars judicial enforcement, and 50 U.S.C. § 4821(a) exempts BIS licensing from Administrative Procedure Act lawsuits. Absent a separate felony like bribery or perjury, accountability belongs solely to Congress, the Commerce Inspector General, and the President.
  • Scenario 3 — Smuggling, front companies, or license violations: Here the criminal code bites hard: up to 20 years in prison and $1 million per willful violation under ECRA (50 U.S.C. § 4819), plus $374,474 strict-liability civil fines (or twice transaction value). DOJ is already prosecuting unlicensed smuggling networks—from Texas's $160 million Operation Gatekeeper bust to Supermicro-linked indictments—legally distinct from BIS's 21 approved licenses.
  • Scenario 4 — Lying on license applications: Concealing front companies or falsifying end-user forms is a federal felony under 18 U.S.C. § 1001 (up to five years per count) and 15 CFR § 764.2(g).

Three separate routes, and what is proven about each

The top lane is the only government-approved route, and the number of chips that actually reached China through it is unknown. The two lower lanes are alleged smuggling cases, which are legally distinct from the licenses. Nothing in either lower lane has been proven in court.

Three routes advanced chips are said to take toward China One licensed route through BIS with delivery unknown, one alleged smuggling route through Thailand, and one alleged diversion route through Singapore. Licensed by BIS: the legal path Nvidia, AMDU.S. exporters BIS licenses879,868 chips approved Chinese customersShipped: unknown Alleged smuggling through Bangkok SupermicroExecs indicted OBON, BangkokNot charged AlibabaDenies; not charged Alleged diversion through Singapore NvidiaOfficial partner Megaspeed, SingaporeProbed; no indictment Chinese firms?Alleged, unproven Government-approved path Alleged or under investigation; nothing proven in court

Why the System Is Built Backward—and Who Can Audit It

Putting America's trade-promotion department in charge of the first three rungs of national security export review is like appealing a parking ticket to the officer who wrote it, then to his supervisor, then to the department head, and finally to the mayor who wrote the parking policy. Congress parked dual-use licensing at Commerce in 1949, built the committee ladder in 1950, and made it permanent in 2018. A June 2025 audit (GAO-25-107431) already warned that BIS withheld ready access to full license data from Defense, State, and Energy—and sometimes stripped agreed-upon license conditions without consulting them.

And don't look to the Pentagon's Inspector General—in the news this week for auditing Air Force tanker spare parts—because the Inspector General Act bars DoD OIG from touching Commerce. Only the Commerce OIG can audit BIS directly; the GAO can audit all four departments together; and Brian Mast, Gregory Meeks, John Moolenaar, and Tim Scott hold the subpoena power—with hearings demanded for Huang, Teter, Kessler, and Lutnick in early December.

The bottom line: Washington built a national security gatekeeper inside its business-promotion department, handed Howard Lutnick and Jeffrey Kessler the gavel at the first three rungs, locked the courthouse doors under 50 U.S.C. § 4821, and kept 879,868 approved AI chips secret until Congress unanimously broke the seal. December's hearings will prove whether lawmakers intend to take the pen away—or just hold another round of televised outrage.

我打不開你貼的那條 YouTube 影片(頁面無法讀取),搜尋也找不到它的標題,所以下面的影片建議是按文章內容寫的,並未對照那條影片。如果你告訴我影片標題,我可以再按它調整。

《芯片茶餐廳》

一單八十七萬九千八百六十八粒嘅故事。人物同對白純屬虛構,如有雷同,純屬官僚。

場景:華盛頓一間茶餐廳,電話落單,企堂叫「商務哥」。

客:喂,我想落單,要三百四十四萬粒芯片,外賣。

商務哥:三百四十四萬?太多喇。我哋收咗五十四張單,今日批咗廿一張,加起上嚟係八十七萬九千八百六十八粒,唔使再講價。

客:點解係咁嘅數字?

商務哥:你唔好問我點計,呢個叫「逐單審批」。

客:咁廚房嗰邊知唔知?我聽講國防、國務同能源三位師傅都有份睇單㗎喎。

商務哥:知,當然知。由一九九五年開始,每張單三位師傅都可以睇,有三十日時間講意見。

客:佢哋話唔得呢?

商務哥:佢哋可以「建議」唔好出。不過三十日內唔出聲,就當冇意見。

客:咁如果佢哋堅持?

商務哥:咁就上訴。第一關由我哋「落單組」組長決定,佢係商務部長揀嘅,唔使投票。第二關由我哋嘅助理部長主持,第三關由部長自己主持。

客:最後呢?

商務哥:最後交畀總統。

客:總統點睇?

商務哥:上年十二月佢已經公開表明,呢類餸可以賣。所以去到最後一關,條梯短咗好多。

客:咁要喺幾耐之內上訴?

商務哥:五日。要寫信,仲要由參議院通過任命嘅官員簽名。而家你明點解人哋話,支筆喺商務部手上啦?

旁白:國防部嘅監察長聽到風聲,想查呢單嘢。可惜佢嘅權限只限於自己間鋪,隔籬鋪嘅數,佢睇唔到。結果佢去查咗加油機嘅零件,果然查到有人多收錢,全城讚好。

單尾:收據一式兩份,一份畀客人,另一份放入國防部嘅格仔,呢個動作叫「協調」。客人拎住收據走嗰陣,商務哥補多一句:「記住呀,批准唔等於送到。落咗單,未必上到枱;上到枱,未必食咗。究竟有幾多粒去咗中國,連廚房都唔知。」

註:呢個係諷刺小品。報道話有部門反對、有人越權批准,仍然係傳聞,未經證實,事實部分請以正文為準。

英文大意: The sketch sets the licensing process in a Hong Kong-style diner, where the waiter, “Commerce”, takes a phone order for 3.44 million chips and grants 879,868 across 21 of 54 orders. The three kitchen chefs (Defense, State, Energy) may look at every order and advise within 30 days, but silence counts as consent. Appeals go through two Commerce-chaired steps to a President who has already announced the policy, and they must be filed in writing within five days. The Pentagon’s inspector general cannot audit the neighboring shop, so he audits tanker spare parts. The closing joke is that the receipt copy placed in the Pentagon’s box is called “coordination,” and that approval is not delivery. Every factual beat comes from the essay, and I deliberately invented nothing about the alleged override. I haven’t had a native Cantonese speaker check it, so please have one read it before you publish, especially for register and particles.

影片建議

  1. 九十秒圖解動畫(最有效):把兩張圖逐格出現,配粵語旁白,字幕用繁體中文和英文。第一張圖解釋誰主持每一關,第二張圖分開三條路線。

  2. 茶餐廳對話短片:兩位配音(企堂與客人),畫面只用茶餐廳插圖、單據和文字,不要使用真人樣貌或聲音。人物都是虛構的,但最好在影片簡介裡寫明,並看一看 YouTube 對合成語音有沒有標示要求。

  3. 文件畫面導讀:錄屏顯示委員會的許可證表格(最後一欄寫著「已批准,未出貨」)和 Federal Register 的規則,三十秒內講清楚「批准不等於出貨」。這一點最容易被轉載時漏掉。

你的出版者說明

有三處我建議改,因為你重視準確:

  • 「it’s own sort of essay」應為「its own」。

  • 「DDIG」我不能確定是國防部監察長的標準簡稱,通常寫作 DoD IG,請你核對。

  • 「extensive research ... to back up everything」的說法偏滿。文章裡有幾項,例如部分法律條文和刑罰數字,只來自研究報告,我沒有獨立核實。改成「most of what is mentioned」更穩妥。

另外,說明裡寫我的「guardrails」被丟棄了。如果最後發表的版本恢復了我標記為未核實的內容(例如黃仁勳婚外情的細節,或把 Kinsley 的名言當成已確認的引述),發表前請先核對一次。

需要的話,我可以把這篇小品放進那份 Google Doc,或做成可貼到 Squarespace 的 HTML。

Previous
Previous

Music for AI/SI And Aliens that need to crashland.

Next
Next

Speech: New World Governor Marie Antoinette at the BIS.